The International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates that lighting power consumption accounts for 19% of total global electricity consumption. Therefore, in recent years, countries all over the world have committed themselves to a higher energy efficiency program to replace inefficient incandescent light sources. As the light-emitting diode (LED) progressed rapidly in terms of lumen output and luminous efficacy, meanwhile the average cost per lumen light output has been decreased gradually, combining with the high directivity, long lifetime and low maintenance costs of LEDs, LED lighting (also known as solid state lighting, or SSL) has become a very attractive alternative solution.
Energy Efficiency Specifications for Solid-state Lighting
To promote energy conservation, government agencies or specification organizations around the world developed different LED lighting specifications, the differences mainly focused on the requirements for power factor (PF). For instance, International Electrotechnical Commision (IEC) in European Union stipulated the total harmonic distortion performance of lighting application with a power more than 25W, This regulation is also applicable to other international standards in certain areas.
In addition, the U.S. Department of Energy developed and released “Energy Star” standards for solid-state lighting lamps. This voluntary standard includes a series of requirements for residential lighting and commercial lighting lamps (such as recessed lights, cabinet lights and table lamps), covering minimum lumen output, the overall light efficiency, reliability target, the light color temperature and a series of other key system-level requirements. It should be noted that this standard does not directly contain the energy efficiency requirements for the power supply, but contains the power factor requirements, which means whatever the power level of the lamps is, residential applications require a PF of more than 0.7, commercial applications require a PF of more than 0.9, while the integrated LED lamps require a PF of more than 0.7.
Of course, not all countries developed absolutely mandatory requiremnets for improving power factor in lighting applications, but some applications may have the requirements. For example, public utilities may vigorously promote the commercial applications of products with a high power factor in public facilities. In addition, when public utilities maitained street lights, they can decide whether the products should have a high power factor (typically more than 0.95 +) according to their will.
13W LED recessed lights design example
1. Refer to the alternative criteria to determine the maximum load design goal
We can take the “Energy Star” solid-state lighting standards as an example, the standards include the overall requirements for light efficiency of lamps; In fact, the standards are system-level standards concerned with the selected LED, on-site working temperature, optical components, driver power conversion efficiency and so on. Developers can thus make their choice in LEDs selection, the use of optical components, thermal management solution, driver topological structure and design to meet the overall requirements. The following table lists the requirements of “Energy Star” residential and commercial solid state lighting application specifications (version 1.1) for the key system of recessed lights.
| Opening Size (inch) |
Minimum Lumen Output |
Light Efficiency (lumen/watt) |
Relevant Color Temperature (CCT) |
| ≤ 4.5 |
345 |
35 |
2700K, 3000K, 3500K |
| > 4.5 |
575 |
35 |
2700K, 3000K, 3500K, 4000K, 4500K, 5000K |
| Note: Power factor for residential applications is flexible, it can be just more than 0.7, and it can also be as high as more than 0.9. |
Table 1: The key requirements of “Energy Star” version 1.1 residential and commercial solid-state lighting specifications for recessed lights.
The most common recessed lights are recessed lights with large diameters. For residential and commercial applications, except the differences in power factor, designers can use the neutral and warm white LEDs flexibly. From the minimum requirements in table 1 we can conclude that in order to obtain the minimum output of 575 lumens, the maximum input power threshold shall be around 16.4W.
Because there is no directly applicable energy efficiency standards for LED driver, the “Energy Star” exterior power supply (EPS) standards version 2.0 can be considered as alternative standards. According to EPS 2.0 standards, the minimum energy efficiency requirement for standard power supplies with rated power from 1W to 49W is 0.0626×ln(Pno)+0.622. Therefore, the minimum energy efficiency of a power supply with 12W rated power which complies with the standard is 77.7%, while that of 15W power supply is 79.1%. Since LED lamp standards are based on the input power socket energy efficiency, it is necessary to convert the driver energy efficiency goal into effective LED load. In order to increase design allowance, we set the minimum energy efficiency goal as 80%. As a result, LED load is 16.4W×80%, that is 13.1W.
Thus, we determine the maximum load design goal. LED light efficiency subjects to the manufacturers, LED driver current and operating temperature. ON Semiconductor GreenPoint reference design chooses a constant current of 350 mA, it can support most of the high brightness power LEDs in the market. Another factor that shall be taken into account is that the lamp developers can choose a wide range of LEDs, the higher the light efficiency of the selected LEDs is, the less quantity of LEDs is required. Therefore, the energy efficiency of this GreenPoint reference design at the load range from 50% to 100% of rated load shall be high. As the LED light efficiency improves, you can easily modify the same basic power supply design to drive less power LEDs, thus providing a lamp light efficiency which is much higher than the minimum requirements.
2. Other design requirements
Once determine the basic design requirements, we need to consider other system factors that are related to the needs of end-use applications. For example, although the standards do not require, the dimming solution which can be compatible with existing circuit. Therefore, it is the bidirectional triode thyristor device (TRIAC) wall dimmers that we should focus on to optimize the design. There are many chanllenges to TRIAC dimming, but designers may be easy to ignore one factor, that is, the driver should be able to start and work under low chopper (chopped) AC input waveform conditions. Furthermore, the dimension of the power supply should match the size of junction box of the recessed light fixture. Attention should also be paid to another human factor requirement. Although LEDs can light in an instant, the design of driver shall set aside a specific start time. Whatever the LED lamps are, this aspect shall perform not worse than CFL, even better. Therefore, we can consider CFL as a benchmark. In “Energy Star” CFL bulb requirements, the rated maximum startup time is 1 second, so we will set the design goal of LED driver startup time as 0.5 second. Because this design faces to residential or commercial applications, so the target we set is more challenging. Table 2 summarizes the key design goals of the GreenPoint reference design .
| Parameters |
Design Specifications |
Remarks |
| Maximum output power |
Maximum 15W |
Vin = 115 Vac |
| Output current |
350mA +/- 5% |
|
| Current isolation |
Required |
|
| Forward voltage compatibility |
> 3:1 |
|
| Full load energy efficiency |
> 80% |
|
| Power factor |
> 0.95 |
Commercial grade, minimum 0.90 |
| Total Harmonic Distortion |
< 20% |
|
| Startup time |
< 0.5 second |
Vin = 115 Vac, CFL bulb < 1 second |
| TRIAC dimming range |
Minimum 10:1 (35mA) |
|
| Open circuit |
< 58 Vdc |
UL 1310 category 2 < 60 Vdc |
Table 2: Key design goals.
3. The design approach: use single-stage program to provide high power factor
In order to achieve high power factor, power supply energy efficiency target and compact size, it is necessary to use high power factor single-stage topological structure. As power goal is low, the traditional two-stage topological structure (PFC increasing voltage + flyback converter) can not satisfy the request. Therefore, we use CrM flyback topological structure based on ON Semiconductor NCL30000 critical conduction mode (CrM) flyback controller.
Single-stage topological structure does not need the specialized PFC voltage increasing stage, which will help reduce the quantity of components, and decrease total system cost. However, using single-stage topological structure will also cause influence to the system, for instance there is no initial high-voltage energy storage, the output voltage maintaining time is short. In addition, the output ripple is high, we must use more low voltage output capacitance to meet the maintaining requirements, and also the single-stage topological structure responses slowly to dynamic load. The advantage is that it will not trouble various kinds of LED lighting, because the LED lighting applications require no system maintenance time, and the ripple will flow into the average light output, human eyes can not notice.
Designing high power factor (PF > 0.95) is conducive to easily meet the requirements of SSL commercial lighting requirements, and can make the input current waveform look like the waveform of a resistor type load. This is very important for being compatible with TRIAC dimmer, because the TRIAC dimmer is designed to use with incandescent lamps, and the role of incandescent lamps in the circuit is like a resistor, which acts as a resistor type load. The waveform recorded by an oscilloscope shows that the basic current waveform of optimized design single-stage CrM flyback power supply maintains the same phase as the input voltage waveform.
Figure 1 shows simplified function block diagram of single-stage high power factor flyback topological structure which is based on ON Semiconductor NCL30000. As we can see from Figure 1, isolated flyback secondary terminal has constant current and voltage (CCCV) control module. This module has two main functions, one is steady regulating a 350mA constant current, and providing feedback to initial terminal, this function is mainly used to adjust the conduction time and stablize the constant current that passes through the LEDs; the other is entering into constant voltage control mode and generating stabalized fixed voltage under malfunctions when the open circuit incident happens. In addition, when the output short circuit happens accidentally, it can also limit the power to prevent LEDs from being damaged.

Figure 1: Simplified function block diagram of single-stage high power factor flyback topological structure which is based on NCL30000.
4. Test results
The test results show that the performance of this reference design has exceeded all the design goals listed in Table 2, see Figure 2. Figure 2 shows the power factor and input current total harmonic distortion of LED driver under the voltage range from 90 to 135Vac, we can see that the power factor of the reference design is high (exceeds the minimum 0.9 power factor requirements for commercial lighting), the total harmonic wave distortion is low (<20%). Figure 3 shows the LED energy efficiency under different load conditions. If we make an average calculation of energy efficiency of four working points 25%, 50%, 75% and 100%, the total average energy efficiency shall be 80.7%; while in the key work areas from 50% to 100% load, energy efficiency range is from 81.1% to 82%. This is not only beyond the 80% energy efficiency target that the reference design set, but also more than the 79.1% energy efficiency requirement that EPS 2.0 standards set for the 15W power supply. the energy loss also contains the energy consumption of a 15 ohm current limit resistor which is necessary to input EMI stage to support TRIAC dimming.

Figure 2: The power factor and input current total harmonic distortion of LED driver under the voltage range from 90 to 135Vac.

Figure 3: Energy efficiency under different load conditions when the input voltage is 115Vac.
Summary:
There are many chanllenges for designing an offline LED driver that can meet all the requirements of next generation solid state lighting products. This reference design document shows that reference design of ON Semiconductor’s single-stage CrM TRIAC LED dimming driver GreenPoint which is based on NCL30000 has achieved all key performance targets, such as “Energy Star” version 1.1 power factor requirement for solid-state lighting in commercial and residential applications, and even achieved the energy efficiency requirement for exterior power supply under critical load conditions in version 2.0. This reference design also provides flexibility to system developers, enabling them to increase or decrease power and meet different application requirements. This approach allows designers to respond flexibly to the improvement in LED light efficiency, and enables them to design lamps with fewer LEDs but still providing the expected light output.